Test time: Why are we doing this?

I’m looking over my daily plans and outlining where our next steps should be today.  And I remember.  We can’t continue our 4th quarter review of writing conventions during that block.  We have to take the practice state test.

Ask a third grader what they think about conventions of writing and you won’t get an enthusiastic response.  But ask them if they’d rather review the basics of capitalization or take an awkward state test (the results of which neither they, nor their teacher will see this year); They will take the rules of proper nouns 10/10 times.

Why are we doing this?  In a school year unlike any other, when articles come out every week lamenting learning loss and gaps from pandemic issues, why are we taking 3 weeks to prepare and take state assessments? 

A cost-benefit analysis is in order.  Here’s what it costs me in time: 

  • 5 hours, preparing and familiarizing students with the test and the tools and review 
  • 6 days where the test takes center stage 

When a test takes center stage for a 9 year old, the rest of the day is NOT business as usual.  

What does it cost me in curriculum pacing?  I’d estimate it may cost us a Chapter in math; it’s making our math practices shallower while we make room for the test.  It’s costing us the richness of literacy experiences (discussions and application) which are traded for surface-level practices instead.  

In this unstable year, there is another cost: Trust.  These students have come to trust their teacher.  They trust their teacher to: 

  • Offer them non-scripted and personal encouragement during a test
  • Teach lessons and give assessments that have a strong and clear purpose

This test is a breach of trust.  We will try to mitigate this breach.  We’ve worked all year on our classroom culture and spent 3 weeks preparing students for these moments.  Most students make it through unscathed.  But I worry about those who do not.  

The test costs us instructional time and trust. The benefits, especially in this uncertain year, are unclear. Why are we doing this?

I will give the test and we will move on; We will overcome this challenge.  That’s what we do. 

10 thoughts on “Test time: Why are we doing this?

  1. Why indeed! Your post brings up some really important points about the cost of these tests. Why would we do them this year or any year for that matter?? But I ask myself this about a lot of different policies..don’t get me started!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The way you have outlined to visible costs is instructional. Considering the time taken away from other instruction over the space of over 20 school days, it’s dumbfounding to imagine that this has become standard practice. Why would we ever choose to engineer a school year which disrupts student trust, learning and well being? Teachers are not the ones who have made this call over and over again. It shows, it shows.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I agree, Tim. “This test is a breach of trust.” Truer words were never spoken. I do not understand why kids needed to be tested this year. (I mean, any year, really. But this year especially.)

    We opted our daughter out of the state tests (our reasoning has nothing to do with Covid). However, the fact that she’s getting 4.5 hours less live instruction/day x 7 days is SUCH A LOSS.

    Here’s to getting through it and getting back to normal… soon!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. We started our state testing today too. (Are you in Indiana?) And I find myself wondering the same thing. I was talking to another teacher last from up north, and her kids were coming into the building for the first time this week…to test!! Why, why, why??

    Like

    1. Illinois. And yes it is not the best use of time anytime but especially in this moment. A student in my wife’s fourth grade classroom said ‘why don’t they just hire people to visit schools and see what’s happening instead of making us take these terrible tests.’…it is not the worst idea I’ve heard!

      Like

  5. You raise some good points here. Bringing to light the cost is an a view that might make some pause and contemplate for a bit. I had thought the pandemic might give us an opportunity to revision some things about education, but it seems there are some things we just can’t let go of even in a pandemic. It seems we are hanging onto the wrong things.

    Like

Leave a Reply to Tim Wheeler Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s